American Psychological Association Past President Defends Change Therapy

“Contending that ‘all same-sex attraction is immutable’ is a distortion of reality.”

This is what American Psychological Association Past President, Nicholas Cummings, said in a USA Today editorial almost ten years ago–before the media blackout on discussion of such ideas became virtually complete:

(July 30, 2013)– “When I was chief psychologist for Kaiser Permanente from 1959 to 1979…I personally saw more than 2,000 patients with same-sex attraction, and my staff saw thousands more.

“They generally sought therapy for one of three reasons: to come to grips with their gay identity, to resolve relationship issues,  or to change their sexual orientation. We would always inform patients in the third group that change was not easily accomplished. With clinical experience, my staff and I learned to assess the probability of change in those who wished to become heterosexual.

“Of the roughly 18,000 gay and lesbian patients whom we treated over 25 years through Kaiser, I believe that most had satisfactory outcomes. The majority were able to attain a happier and more stable homosexual lifestyle. Of the patients I oversaw who sought to change their orientation, hundreds were successful.

“I believe that our rate of success with reorientation was relatively high because we were selective in recommending therapeutic change efforts only to those who identified themselves as highly motivated and were clinically assessed as having a high probability of success.

“Since then, the role of psychotherapy in sexual orientation change efforts has been politicized. Gay and lesbian rights activists appear to be convincing the public that homosexuality is one identical, inherited characteristic. To my dismay, some in the organized mental health community seem to agree, including the American Psychological Association, though I don’t believe that view is supported by scientific evidence.

“Gays and lesbians have the right to be affirmed in their homosexuality. That’s why, as a member of the APA Council of Representatives in 1975, I sponsored the resolution by which the APA stated that homosexuality is not a mental disorder and, in 1976, the resolution, which passed the council unanimously, that gays and lesbians should not be discriminated against in the workplace.

“But contending that “all same-sex attraction is immutable” is a distortion of reality. Attempting to characterize all sexual reorientation therapy as “unethical” violates patient choice and gives an outside party a veto over patients’ goals for their own treatment. A political agenda shouldn’t prevent gays and lesbians who desire to change from making their own decisions.

“Whatever the situation at an individual clinic, accusing professionals from across the country who provide treatment for fully informed persons seeking to change their sexual orientation of perpetrating a ‘fraud’ serves only to stigmatize the professional and shame the patient.”

Nicholas Cummings was president of the American Psychological Association (1979-80).